Montana Residency Audits
Moving to Montana, leaving Montana or splitting the year between two states can lead to a residency audit. The state you left may say you never really moved. Montana may say you never really left. Montana Tax Law Firm PC represents individuals in residency audits and appeals on both sides of the state line, from offices in Kalispell and Missoula.
Why residency audits happen
A resident is generally taxed on all of their income, wherever it is earned. A nonresident is generally taxed only on income from sources in that state. Because so much tax turns on where you live, states look closely at people who claim to have moved, especially people with high income, a business, stock sales or retirement income in the year they moved.
Moving to Montana from another state
Montana keeps attracting new residents from Washington, California, Oregon, Minnesota, Colorado, Illinois and New York. A former state may audit whether you actually changed your domicile, especially if you kept a home, a business, a professional license or family ties there. Many states also apply a day-count test, so the number of days you spend there after the move can matter.
Leaving Montana or splitting your time
The Montana Department of Revenue also reviews people who claim to have left Montana, as well as people who keep a home here while spending part of the year elsewhere. If you still have a permanent home in Montana, the department may question whether you really gave up Montana residency.
How Montana decides who is a resident
For Montana individual income tax, you may be a resident if you are domiciled in Montana or maintain a permanent place of abode in Montana. Residency is determined from all the facts and circumstances, including your intentions. The department considers factors such as:
- Where your driver’s license, vehicle registrations and voter registration are
- Where you own or rent a home, and where your family lives
- Where you receive mail and get regular medical and professional care
- Where you work, run a business, bank and keep professional licenses
- Where you file tax returns and claim residency for other purposes
No single factor decides the question, and you don’t need to meet every factor to be treated as a resident. Montana also recognizes part-year residents: people who start the year as residents of one state and establish residency in another during the year. Seasonal residents who don’t establish residency elsewhere are generally not part-year residents.
Residency documentation checklist
Whether you are moving in or moving out, these records often decide a residency audit. Start keeping them in the year you move.
- A calendar or log of where you were each day, backed by phone, credit card and travel records
- Your new driver’s license, vehicle registration and voter registration, with their dates
- The purchase or lease of your new home, and the sale, lease or change of use of the old one
- Address changes with banks, brokers, employers, insurers and the IRS
- New doctors, dentists, accountants and other professionals
- Club, church and community memberships, joined and resigned
- Where business and employment activity takes place, and where you work remotely from
- Where important personal items, pets and family keepsakes are kept
How we help with residency audits
Attorney Daniel P. Knudsen has more than 10 years of tax controversy experience and holds an LL.M. in Taxation, with certificates in State and Local Tax and in Tax Litigation Practice and Procedure. He is licensed in Montana and 13 other jurisdictions, including Washington, Minnesota, New York, Colorado and Illinois, which lets him address both sides of a multistate residency dispute. The firm can help with:
- Responding to residency questionnaires and audit letters from Montana or another state
- Organizing the evidence of where you lived and when you moved
- Part-year and nonresident return positions and income allocation
- Appeals of a residency assessment, including Montana’s written objection, the Office of Dispute Resolution and the Montana Tax Appeal Board
- Planning a move so the records support your new residency from the start
Deadlines matter. Montana generally allows 45 days to file a written objection to most Department of Revenue decisions, and other states set their own deadlines. Call as soon as you receive a residency questionnaire or assessment.
Residency audit FAQs
I moved to Montana. Why is my old state still sending me letters? States often review the year someone moves away, especially when the person kept property, a business or other ties there. A letter or questionnaire is the start of that review, and your answers can shape the outcome.
Is getting a Montana driver’s license enough to become a Montana resident? No. A driver’s license is one factor among many. A residency decision looks at the whole picture, including your home, family, work and where you spend your time.
Can two states both claim I am a resident? Yes. Two states can each claim you as a resident for the same year. Credits for taxes paid to another state may reduce double taxation, but they don’t always eliminate it, so it pays to resolve the residency question directly.
I spend winters out of state. Am I still a Montana resident? Possibly. If you keep your domicile or a permanent home in Montana, Montana may still treat you as a resident, even if you spend months elsewhere.
Can you represent me with a state other than Montana? Daniel P. Knudsen is licensed in Montana, Washington, North Dakota, Wyoming, Colorado, Utah, Texas, South Dakota, Illinois, Minnesota, New York, the District of Columbia, South Carolina and North Carolina. Call to discuss which state is involved.
Talk to us about a residency audit
Call (406) 300-5863 to schedule an appointment at our Kalispell office or Missoula office. Office visits are by appointment only, and many matters can be handled by phone and video.